Sky Sports cricket experts Michael Atherton and Nasser Hussain have described England's recent Ashes victory at the Melbourne Cricket Ground as a "hollow" triumph, emphasizing how the series might have unfolded differently with improved early preparation.

Mixed Emotions After Historic Win

England ended a 15-year winless streak in Australia during a dramatic two-day Test at the MCG, avoiding a potential 5-0 whitewash. However, the achievement was overshadowed by reflections on their earlier struggles in Perth, Brisbane, and Adelaide.

"I'm delighted for Ben Stokes, Joe Root, and the fans, but this feels like a hollow victory considering what could have been," Atherton remarked. "It's almost absurd that England only became competitive after playing some proper cricket."

Preparation Shortcomings Exposed

The tourists faced criticism for their limited warm-up matches, with head coach Brendon McCullum admitting their single intra-squad game against England Lions was likely insufficient. Batting collapses and technical flaws further compounded their challenges early in the series.

Hussain expressed frustration, stating: "If England had focused properly from the start, we could be looking at a 2-2 scoreline heading into Sydney. This win only highlights their initial lack of preparation."

Bright Spots in Melbourne

Youngster Jacob Bethell emerged as a positive, scoring a crucial 40 runs in England's second innings. Hussain praised the Warwickshire batsman, noting his potential despite limited red-ball experience.

Key Match Figures

  • Australia 1st innings: 152 all out (Tongue 5-45)
  • England 1st innings: 110 all out (Brook 41)
  • Result: England won by 65 runs

As the teams prepare for the final Test in Sydney, questions linger about England's missed opportunities and Australia's weakened bowling attack, absent key players like Pat Cummins and Nathan Lyon.